Tucked on Beekman Avenue, Justin's Deli is where neighbors come for oven-fresh sandwiches, carefully pulled espresso shots, and the kind of counter service that remembers your name.
Single-origin beans, pulled fresh throughout the day.
Bread, soups, and desserts made in-house every morning.
Produce and meats from nearby farms and purveyors.
Fast counter service with a smile — no wait needed.
Justin's Deli started as a simple idea: serve honest food in a place where people actually want to linger. Today, we're still doing exactly that — just with a few more regulars and a much better coffee machine.
Our bread, soups, and salad dressings are prepared each morning — never from a box, never from yesterday.
We know most of our regulars by name. If you're new, we'll remember you after one visit.
Deli meats from local providers, produce from regional farms, coffee roasted within the state.
Every item on the counter has a reason to be there. If we wouldn't serve it to our own family, it doesn't make the menu.
Slow-roasted pastrami, gruyère, caramelized onions, and our house mustard on toasted sourdough. The one people drive past Tarrytown for.
Single-origin pour-overs and well-pulled espresso drinks, made to order. Pair it with a fresh pastry from our daily batch.
Rotating daily soups made from scratch — think roasted tomato basil, lentil, and the kind of chicken noodle that actually tastes like comfort.
The counter, the coffee, the regulars — this is what a Tuesday looks like at Justin's.
Don't take our word for it — here's what our regulars have to say.
"I come here every Wednesday before work. The coffee is consistently the best in Sleepy Hollow, and the staff actually remembers how I take my order. That matters."
"Brought out-of-town friends here and they couldn't stop talking about the melt. The bread is incredible — you can tell it's made here. Already planning our next visit."
"Finally a place in town that does soup right. The lentil was outstanding this week. Cozy spot, quick service, and the prices actually make sense. My go-to lunch."
Find us on Beekman Avenue in the heart of Sleepy Hollow. Walk-ins are always welcome — or give us a call if you're planning a catered spread for the office.
